18 Scrumptious Stuffed Banana Pepper Recipes (Cheese, Sausage, and More) for a Delicious Dinner Party

Posted on September 10, 2025 by Maryann Desmond

Keep in mind that stuffed banana peppers are often relegated to secondary roles in various dishes, such as sandwiches, pizza toppings, and salads, where they add a sweet tanginess. However, it’s high time to give them the starring role they deserve! With their delicate flavor begging to be showcased, these recipes offer an ideal opportunity to do just that.

Each filling is carefully crafted to highlight the peppers’ subtle nuances, incorporating ingredients like Italian sausage, potatoes, and generous helpings of cheese. If you’ve grown tired of the usual stuffed green and jalapeno pepper options, now’s the perfect time to shake things up with these innovative stuffed banana pepper recipes!

Italian Sausage Stuffed Banana Peppers

Italian Sausage Stuffed Banana Peppers

Bring your taste buds to life with a dish that’s sure to become a new favorite. This hearty recipe is bursting with vibrant flavors, making it perfect for anyone looking to add some excitement to their mealtime routine. The best part? It’s surprisingly easy to prepare, even for those who are new to cooking. With its rich cream cheese and shredded Italian cheese blend, this dish is sure to satisfy your cravings.

Plus, it’s not only delicious but also gluten-free and low in carbs, making it a great option for those with dietary restrictions. Pair it with a fresh garden salad for the ultimate indulgent dinner experience.

Stuffed Banana Peppers (Beef)

Stuffed Banana Peppers (Beef)

Beneath its humble appearance, stuffed green peppers offer an incredible depth of flavor and versatility. But what happens when you swap out the traditional green pepper for something new? In this case, using banana peppers instead completely transforms the dish, infusing the beef stuffing with a slightly sweet and delicate heat that’s reminiscent of Italian cuisine.

Editor Choice:  35 Scrumptious Appetizer Recipes For Every Party and Gathering

Whether you’re serving it as a full meal or as part of a hearty appetizer platter at your next potluck, the result is always a crowd-pleaser.

Three Meat Stuffed Italian Banana Peppers

Three Meat Stuffed Italian Banana Peppers

Savoring the flavors of Italy, this dish takes a unique twist on traditional enchiladas. With its rich, cheesy goodness and spicy kick, it’s also low-carb-friendly. The key to these mouth-watering meaty stuffed Italian banana peppers lies in a special sauce that adds depth and flavor. This sauce is a game-changer as it perfectly complements the hearty mixture of meats with the subtle heat from the banana peppers.

The banana pepper sauce, while reminiscent of marinara, gets an infusion of herbs and a boost of heat from red chili pepper flakes, making each bite a delightful experience.

Cheese Stuffed Banana Peppers

Cheese Stuffed Banana Peppers

Diving into this recipe, you’ll discover an abundance of cheese that’s sure to satisfy any fromage enthusiast. The mild banana peppers serve as the perfect vehicle for a generous helping of cream cheese, cheddar cheese, and a blend of rich spices that add depth to each bite. As you wrap the banana peppers in a strip of smoky bacon, the grill brings out their natural flavor, leaving them slightly charred but still tender.

This tasty snack is sure to be a showstopper at your next gathering or party.

Stuffed Banana Pepper Bites

Stuffed Banana Pepper Bites

A twist on traditional stuffed banana peppers, this recipe takes each serving size down a notch by cutting them into smaller, snack-sized portions. This makes for a perfect party appetizer when you want something bite-sized instead of an entire banana pepper stuffed with filling. Each piece is still packed with a bold blend of cream cheese and bright spices, but now breaded and baked in the oven to perfection.

Editor Choice:  20 Delightful Dry Soup in a Jar Creations

Although they may take a little more time to assemble, the extra effort is well worth it, yielding a delicious and satisfying snack.

Stuffed Banana Peppers (with Chorizo, Goat Cheese, Basil & Chives)

Stuffed Banana Peppers (with Chorizo, Goat Cheese, Basil & Chives)

Zeroing in on bold flavors, these stuffed banana peppers are a game-changer for any gathering. Spicy chorizo and tangy goat cheese are expertly paired with mild banana peppers – but be warned, the pepper gods may have other plans! You might just get stuck with one of the rare hot ones, adding an extra layer of excitement to your dish. To balance out the heat, they’re lightly breaded with panko breadcrumbs and baked until golden and delicious in the oven.

As a result, they make the perfect show-stopping appetizer for any potluck or party.

Potato And Olive Stuffed Banana Peppers

Potato And Olive Stuffed Banana Peppers

Generally speaking, creating filling stuffed peppers is a great way to get started with this Mediterranean-inspired dish. The hash-like filling is infused with the bright flavors of olives, garlic, and herbs, which not only add depth but also keep high-calorie ingredients like cheese or sausage at bay. Although these peppers are technically healthy and lower in calories, they’re certainly not low on flavor.

What’s more, this recipe checks all the right boxes for various diets – it’s vegan, Paleo-friendly, and Whole30-approved, making it accessible to a wide range of eaters.

Bob’s Stuffed Banana Peppers

Bob’s Stuffed Banana Peppers

Making a killer dish can be intimidating, but with the right combination of flavors and ingredients, even the most novice cooks can create something truly exceptional. In this case, Bob’s stuffed banana pepper recipe is a masterclass in simplicity and flavor. The dish is built around hearty Italian sausages, which add a meaty and slightly spicy kick to the rich tomato base. The addition of cheese and breadcrumbs provides a satisfying depth and texture that elevates the entire experience.

Editor Choice:  26 Irresistible Finger Food Appetizers On Sticks Perfect For Parties

Be warned, this main course is incredibly addictive, and its popularity will quickly lead to high demand for more – making it a staple in any household. But don’t just take our word for it, head over to the recipe to see what all the fuss is about.

Stuffed Banana Peppers (in Marinara Sauce)

Stuffed Banana Peppers (in Marinara Sauce)

Presented as an ideal weeknight meal option, stuffed banana peppers with homemade marinara offer a satisfying experience while keeping carbs relatively low. Preparing a homemade marinara may require more time and effort than purchasing it from a store, but the difference in taste is well worth the extra effort. This marinara recipe relies on basic pantry staples and can be prepared quickly, making it an efficient choice.

Fill your peppers with a bold blend of Italian sausage and herbs, then top them with homemade marinara and melted cheese. After baking to perfection, the dish emerges bubbly, savory, and delightful, suitable for both main courses and side dishes at social gatherings or potlucks.

Bacon Wrapped Banana Peppers Stuffed with Sweet Potato

Bacon Wrapped Banana Peppers Stuffed with Sweet Potato

You might also like these recipes

Leave a Comment