27+ Scrumptious Fall Cookie Recipes To Make At Home

Posted on September 26, 2025 by Maryann Desmond

Reflecting on the upcoming fall holidays, it’s no surprise that I’m craving sweet treats to celebrate the season. With Halloween and Thanksgiving just around the corner, my thoughts turn to warm spices, crunchy textures, and comforting flavors – all hallmarks of delicious fall cookies. If you’re like me, then you’ll appreciate these recipe ideas that cater to your cravings for seasonal sweets.

From classic pumpkin oatmeal cookies to innovative apple butter snickerdoodles, I’m confident that you’ll discover something on this list that will become the star of your holiday party dessert table. Don’t forget to scroll down and download the free meal planner printable – it’s a great resource to help you plan your menus for the season.

Chocolate Jack-O-Lantern Sugar Cookies Delight

Chocolate Jack-O-Lantern Sugar Cookies Delight

Zest up your Halloween celebrations with these unique milk chocolate stuffed jack-o-lantern cookies. As the fall season approaches and everyone’s favorite holiday draws near, it’s time to get creative in the kitchen. This recipe is sure to impress your guests with its creative twist on traditional Halloween treats. Simply break out that cookie cutter and get baking! Don’t forget to share this post or pin this delicious recipe to your Pinterest board for later use.

If you need a weekly meal planner printable, check out my free one HERE – no email required.

Fall Triple Chocolate Treats in a Flash

Fall Triple Chocolate Treats in a Flash

Joining the ranks of delicious seasonal treats are these mouthwatering Fall cookies, featuring a rich blend of milk chocolate, white chocolate, and semi-sweet chocolate. The beauty of this recipe lies in its simplicity, requiring only thirty minutes to prepare – perfect for when you need a quick dessert fix.

Autumn’s Sweet Caramel Apple Delight

Autumn

A delightful twist on traditional fall treats is in order, as caramel apple cookies take center stage alongside their pumpkin counterparts. Soft, chewy, and infused with the perfect balance of sweet and tangy flavors, these baked goods are sure to become a new favorite. The recipe itself provides valuable insight into selecting the ideal type of apples for optimal results, ensuring an exceptional baking experience.

Pumpkin Oatmeal Cookies with a Soft Twist

Pumpkin Oatmeal Cookies with a Soft Twist

Keeping in mind the temptation of indulging in sweet treats, we’ve come up with a recipe for soft and delicious pumpkin oatmeal cookies. These cookies are a game-changer not just because they taste amazing, but also because they’re relatively healthy – or at least that’s what I keep telling myself! The beauty of this recipe lies in its customization options; you can experiment with various combinations of ingredients to create your perfect treat.

Related Recipe Post: Quick & Easy Thanksgiving CupcakesThese pumpkin oatmeal cookies are a must-try, and we’re confident that once you take a bite, you’ll be hooked. The best part? You can enjoy them guilt-free (or at least that’s the idea!)

Editor Choice:  30 Decadent Homemade Brownie Recipes to Satisfy Your Late-Night Cravings!

Cozy Pumpkin Pie Slice Cookies Delight

Cozy Pumpkin Pie Slice Cookies Delight

Packed with the essence of fall, these adorable mini pumpkin pie slice cookies are sure to infuse a sense of warmth into any occasion. Whether you’re baking them up in your kitchen or taking them along as a special treat for Thanksgiving, their small size and cute design make them the perfect little indulgence that’s hard to resist. The best part? These delicious cookies capture the very essence of fall, making them an ideal seasonal treat to brighten up any celebration.

Sugar Cookie Pies Recipe for Holiday Cheer

Sugar Cookie Pies Recipe for Holiday Cheer

You’ll find a delightful treat in Jenny Cookies, an ideal recipe to test your baking skills while creating adorable sugar cookie pies. Not only do these treats look incredible, but they’re also relatively simple to prepare. The best part is that their appearance and taste are perfectly balanced, making them the perfect addition to any holiday party. They’ll surely bring a smile to everyone’s face!

Pumpkin Kiss Cookies for Fall Baking

Pumpkin Kiss Cookies for Fall Baking

Delightful Fall treats are a staple in many households, and for good reason. The season lends itself perfectly to baking, and one of the most iconic ingredients of all – pumpkin – takes center stage. In particular, these blossom cookies rely on the sweet charm of pumpkin spice Hershey’s kisses. What makes this recipe truly special is not only its mouth-watering taste but also its adorable appearance, with a tiny pumpkin perched atop each cookie, making them almost too cute to eat.

Apple Caramel Cookie Decorating Tutorial

Apple Caramel Cookie Decorating Tutorial

Here at The Cake Blog, we’re always on the lookout for exciting new ways to elevate our favorite baked goods. If you’re craving something sweet and fun, then look no further! This tutorial is specifically designed for those who want to try their hand at making caramel apple cookies. Not only will it guide you through the process of creating these tasty treats, but also show you how to top them off with a delicious caramel flood icing – the perfect finishing touch.

We think you’ll be hooked from the very first bite…

Mini Apple Pie Bites from the Netherlands

Mini Apple Pie Bites from the Netherlands

Often when the fall season arrives with its rainy weather, many of us tend to retreat to the kitchen in search of comfort food. It’s during these cozy moments that baking delicious treats becomes a delightful escape. One such scrumptious delight is the Dutch apple pie cookie, which has stolen our hearts with its irresistible charm and delectable taste. So, why not try your hand at making some? We guarantee you’ll be hooked by their irresistible small size and adorable presentation.

Maple Pecan Scone Cookies with Glaze

Maple Pecan Scone Cookies with Glaze

Finding simplicity in baking is a refreshing change of pace, and these pecan maple cookies embody this concept perfectly. With a delicate balance of crunchy pecans topped with a rich, mouth-filling maple glaze, these treats are surprisingly uncomplicated. The inclusion of raw sugar adds depth to their texture, making each bite a delight. According to the recipe, they’re designed to resemble scones more than traditional cookies, so if you enjoy that style, you’ll likely fall in love with them.

Editor Choice:  26 Delicious Strawberry Rhubarb Recipes for a Sweet Brunch

To get started on creating these sweet treats, be sure to check out the accompanying recipe and follow along as it guides you through the process.

Easy Peanut Butter Treats for Kids

Easy Peanut Butter Treats for Kids

Generally speaking, peanut butter cookies are hard to beat. As Fall approaches, it’s time to whip up a new treat that’s quick and easy to make, especially when your little ones suddenly develop a sweet tooth.

Pumpkin Spice Up Classic Cookies

Pumpkin Spice Up Classic Cookies

Gather around the kitchen counter to experience a delightful twist on traditional pudding cookies. The arrival of Fall brings with it an opportunity to infuse seasonal flavors into classic treats. As everyone knows, pumpkin is the quintessential flavor of this time of year. Why not take advantage of that? Add some warmth and coziness to your baked goods by incorporating pumpkin into these soft-baked pudding cookies.

Fortunately, you can make them easily with a tried-and-true recipe that includes helpful video instructions to guide you through the process. Get ready to indulge in a delicious new spin on an old favorite – Pumpkin Pudding Cookies are just around the corner!

Toasty Marshmallow Toffee Family Treats

Toasty Marshmallow Toffee Family Treats

Rustic afternoons spent baking with loved ones are truly one of life’s greatest joys. On a drizzly November day, why not gather your family together and make some scrumptious marshmallow toffee cookies? Not only will you be creating unforgettable memories with your nearest and dearest, but you’ll also be indulging in the most mouthwatering treats that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. That’s a win-win situation indeed!

Pumpkin Spice Snickerdoodle Delights

Pumpkin Spice Snickerdoodle Delights

Here’s the exciting news: Melissas Southern Style Kitchen has a special treat for you! Imagine snickerdoodles, but with a delicious twist – we’re adding the warmth of pumpkin to this classic cookie recipe. This sweet fusion requires just over thirty minutes to prepare, making it a quick and tasty addition to your baking repertoire. And let’s be honest, anything with pumpkin spice is always a winner in my book!

Cinnamon Swirl Apple Butter Cookies

Cinnamon Swirl Apple Butter Cookies

Yearning for something truly special this fall season? You’re in luck because these Apple Butter Snickerdoodles are a game-changer. With the warmth of cinnamon and the sweetness of apple butter, it’s no wonder this combination has been a classic pairing for centuries. As the temperatures drop and the holidays approach, you’ll want to have these heavenly bites on hand to impress your guests.

Editor Choice:  32 Delicious Recipes Using Pineapple Jello For Sweet Treats

Mini Peanut Butter Cup Treats Recipe

Mini Peanut Butter Cup Treats Recipe

Harnessing your love for peanut butter, this recipe is a must-try for you! This Fall season, indulge in these scrumptious mini cup cookies that are sure to become an instant favorite. With this step-by-step tutorial, not only will you learn how to make these delicious treats, but also discover some expert tips and tricks to ensure they turn out perfectly – just like the picture!

Of course, we all know that sometimes reality doesn’t quite match up to Pinterest perfection, but don’t worry, with a little practice, your creations will be almost as stunning. So go ahead, grab your family, and get baking!

Marble Chocolate Chip Cookies Perfect for Harvest Season

Marble Chocolate Chip Cookies Perfect for Harvest Season

Need a change from traditional pie at your Thanksgiving gathering? Consider whipping up some delicious harvest marble chocolate-chip cookies instead! To get started, you’ll need a combination of butter, brown sugar, and granulated sugar. For the full recipe with step-by-step instructions, check out our detailed tutorial that guides you through the process of making these tasty treats for yourself.

Heavenly Maple Sugar Crinkle Cookies

Heavenly Maple Sugar Crinkle Cookies

Stunningly delicious, Sally’s Baking Addiction knows how to create a culinary masterpiece with their ‘maple brown sugar cookies’. The moment I hear this phrase, my mind immediately transports me to a sweet haven. If you’re planning on baking these irresistible treats, don’t overlook the importance of letting the cookie dough chill in the freezer for at least two hours.

Trust us, once you indulge in those crispy edges, it’ll be impossible to resist their charm and return to a life without them – yes, they are that good!

Brown Sugar Pecan Treats

Brown Sugar Pecan Treats

With many people having a sweet tooth, pecan desserts are always in high demand. Whether it’s the rich flavor of butter or the crunch of toasted nuts, these treats can’t be beat. This particular recipe combines the best of both worlds with brown butter, brown sugar, and crunchy toasted butter pecans – the perfect ingredients to make your taste buds sing. Let’s get baking!

Pumpkin Toffee Sugar Cookies for Fall

Pumpkin Toffee Sugar Cookies for Fall

Welcome to the sweetest time of the year – Fall! A season that’s all about cozying up with warm spices and indulging in delicious treats. That’s why we’re excited to share this simple yet mouth-watering cookie recipe for pumpkin sugar cookies infused with the rich flavor of toffee spice. And the best part?

You can get creative by cutting them into any shape you desire, whether it’s a classic circle or an intricate design, and decorating them with your favorite toppings – the possibilities are endless!

You might also like these recipes

Leave a Comment